|
Focus
first on goals and values, instead of taxes.
In making a business
or investment decision, most people identify their goals first and then explore tax-efficient ways
to meet those goals. Yet,
in our experience, this process is usually reversed in planning to
give money away, rather than make it.
In planning their giving,
individuals in the U.S. often give foremost attention to saving taxes –
charitable remainder trusts for income tax saving, charitable lead
trusts for estate and gift tax saving, and private foundations for
saving taxes across generations. The
selection of less common alternatives, such as a support organization
or donor-advised fund, is often made to achieve greater tax benefits,
and not to gain the intangible benefits that those alternatives can
provide. This tendency to give
priority to tax issues mistakenly puts the means before the ends. It
prematurely narrows the pathway of productive thinking.
Make
goals your first priority, then ways and means. Start by asking
questions.
|
|
¨ |
Beyond saving taxes, why do I need a private foundation?
| |
As
a family activity? To promote family values, and if so, whose values? Can my great grandchildren spend
"my money" to finance views that I
oppose? Who has a stake in the future of my foundation?
|
|
| |
¨ |
Do I believe private charities can make
government programs more effective?
| |
Do I value policy-making over field work?
Do I value planning for a better world over relief
of
current suffering?
|
|
| |
¨ |
Do my words reveal my intentions? What if
circumstances change?
| |
What if I endow a zoo and zoos become obsolete?
Why did I fund the zoo? To support
fun activities for children? Or because I like
animals, or zoology, or the zoo's educational
message or radical new design? Did I believe my community
needed a new tourist attraction?
Was the zoo director my close friend?
|
|
| |
¨ |
What is the true value of the tax dollars
saved by the proposed gift?
| |
Are the savings realized currently, and who
benefits?
Do the savings simply increase the size of my estate that
will
pass to charity later? If so, at what cost in loss
of
flexibility?
Have I overlooked something else that my
family truly
cares about?
|
|
| |
¨ |
If I believe globalization is a long–term
trend, why is all my giving coming to rest in the United
States? Why is my foundation here? Is this myopic?
|
| |
¨ |
Have I overlooked choices and opportunities
to deal with change?
|
| |
¨ |
Do I know how most wealthy families choose
to plan their
philanthropy? Do I know why those are the customary choices?
Do I want to choose that path?
|
 |